Lisa Howard
as Linda Gufstafson and Gladys Turnakit
Sims Lamason
as Lorraine Stubenski
Catherine Ashmore Bradley
as Little Lorraine/Dori
Graham Stevens
as Trip
Will Boyajian
as Dov Yisrael
Doug Shapiro
as Bob/Coach Ivan
Paige Sommerer
as Deacon Andrea Doekstra
Nick Abbott
as David, Jimmy and Alan Thicke
Micah Mims
as Ray-Ray
Alia Munsch
as Tammy and Stephanie